NFL
Re: NFL
almost as bad as the phantom defensive holding penalty called on Luke Wilson of the Bengals last year - but at least it looked a little like holding this time
shady shit - that's why i dont bet
but im glad the Chiefs won
Re: NFL
You’re a ref, you see the jersey grab, and you reach for your flag and throw it once the ball is thrown in the direction of the receiver. This is text book.
People confused about this are the same types marveling at McKinnon stopping at the 1 yard line instead of scoring. It’s exactly what should happen.
Re: NFL
Sure it's a hold, just like holds that get called and uncalled all game long. Just surprised that the ref waited, then thought it impacted the outcome of the play. Would you say that a flag should have been thrown, even if the ball wasn't thrown in his direction? If yes, why wait? If no, then the hold must have impeded the intended receiver from catching the ball? Isn't that pass interference?
Again, ref has grounds to make the call, just don't know why he would in this case.
Again, ref has grounds to make the call, just don't know why he would in this case.
Re: NFL
That’s rarely how it works. The ref sees it, reaches for the flag and then throws it after Pat attempts the throw to that receiver. He eats that flag otherwise. You see it all the time. Especially in big games. Holding isn’t often called away from the play unless it’s egregious. And it’s not DPI because it happened before the ball was thrown.mockbee wrote: ↑Fri Feb 17, 2023 3:01 pmSure it's a hold, just like holds that get called and uncalled all game long. Just surprised that the ref waited, then thought it impacted the outcome of the play. Would you say that a flag should have been thrown, even if the ball wasn't thrown in his direction? If yes, why wait? If no, then the hold must have impeded the intended receiver from catching the ball? Isn't that pass interference?
Again, ref has grounds to make the call, just don't know why he would in this case.
I am rarely a homer when it comes to stuff like this. I enjoy the sport more by being honest with myself about whether something is a legitimate foul or not. There’s nothing worse than that fan that won’t shut the fuck up about every call not in their favor. As if the whole league is rigged against their team, every game.
That said, I wouldn’t have extremely upset had it not been called. But it’s definitely a hold. And that’s the bottom line. The refs should never be thinking about the gravity of a flag. It should be as robotic as possible. And there are penalties missed every game. So crying about it not being called earlier is nonsense. That happens every game.
If your ability to win a game is impacted by one flag, you fucked up. Unless it’s a BS flag. Which the picture I posted alone proves it wasn’t. You grab a fistful of jersey and you’re gambling hard. Even the defender admits that.
Re: NFL
You act like the flag was thrown an hour later. This is the only place I’ve read anyone complain about when the flag was thrown versus the fact that it was thrown at all. It’s very normal.
Bottom line, it was a hold. The end.
Re: NFL
Using your logic and previous statements, the reason the ref waited was to see if the hold impacted the play, ball overthrown, and as you said hold didn't impact the play.
No harm, no foul, why throw it and end the game on a call?
Okay, but same could be said for all the holds not called.Bottom line, it was a hold. The end.
It's the same logic.
You're acting like there is no nuance and the refs are robots. All I'm saying is wouldn't you want a game that doesnt end on a call if the call could go either way?
It was just a goof, ref is human.
Re: NFL
They don’t tend to concern themselves with the ball being overthrown unless it’s egregious, and only on DPI. You’re not following.mockbee wrote: ↑Sun Feb 19, 2023 4:40 pmUsing your logic and previous statements, the reason the ref waited was to see if the hold impacted the play, ball overthrown, and as you said hold didn't impact the play.
No harm, no foul, why throw it and end the game on a call?
Okay, but same could be said for all the holds not called.Bottom line, it was a hold. The end.
It's the same logic.
You're acting like there is no nuance and the refs are robots. All I'm saying is wouldn't you want a game that doesnt end on a call if the call could go either way?
It was just a goof, ref is human.
And I don’t care the method for how the game ends. As long as it’s a legitimate call. And it was. Also, the Eagles did get the ball back. And for some reason Hurts threw a lame duck. They should have been immediately lateraling that.
The Eagles themselves are complaining less than people in the thread. They understand that the game is won or lost over the other 59 1/2 minutes. They’ve acknowledged it was a hold. If the professionals that were impacted are able to concede what happened, then the fans should be able to as well.
Re: NFL
You're the one who said the pass initiated the flag on the hold they weren't going to call otherwise.Hokahey wrote: ↑Sun Feb 19, 2023 8:08 pmThey don’t tend to concern themselves with the ball being overthrown unless it’s egregious, and only on DPI. You’re not following.mockbee wrote: ↑Sun Feb 19, 2023 4:40 pmUsing your logic and previous statements, the reason the ref waited was to see if the hold impacted the play, ball overthrown, and as you said hold didn't impact the play.
No harm, no foul, why throw it and end the game on a call?
Okay, but same could be said for all the holds not called.Bottom line, it was a hold. The end.
It's the same logic.
You're acting like there is no nuance and the refs are robots. All I'm saying is wouldn't you want a game that doesnt end on a call if the call could go either way?
It was just a goof, ref is human.
But, yea, whatever hurts pass sucked. game over
Re: NFL
Tyreek Hill and Falcons RB Bijan Robinson gave their list of top 5 running back of all time
Tyreek:
Adrian Peterson
Derrick Henry
Barry Sanders
Gale Sayers
Eric Dickerson
Bijan:
Barry Sanders
LaDainian Tomlinson
Marshall Faulk
Adrian Peterson
Walter Payton
Here's mine
Walter Payton
Jim Brown
Gale Sayers
OJ
Earl Campbell
I win that one
Tyreek:
Adrian Peterson
Derrick Henry
Barry Sanders
Gale Sayers
Eric Dickerson
Bijan:
Barry Sanders
LaDainian Tomlinson
Marshall Faulk
Adrian Peterson
Walter Payton
Here's mine
Walter Payton
Jim Brown
Gale Sayers
OJ
Earl Campbell
I win that one
Re: NFL
5 is so hard now...when I was younger it was easy
brown
sayers
oj
Payton
sanders
now time has added bo, marcus, ad, lt and faulk
then the undeniable bruisers...like earl, henry, bettis
all that and I haven't mentioned smith, tony or Dickerson! (most hated was Eric...I was sooo bummed when the LA Rams got him it was the beginning of the end for me as a Rams fan...Vince farragamo and dick
fuck tens impossible now...try doing 20...then you get to csonka, motley, fuck cutis martin? ed James? so hard now...best with my eyes in my life? Bo and Barry....best ever? Jim....my all-time favs in order? Gale, Marcus, LT...
brown
sayers
oj
Payton
sanders
now time has added bo, marcus, ad, lt and faulk
then the undeniable bruisers...like earl, henry, bettis
all that and I haven't mentioned smith, tony or Dickerson! (most hated was Eric...I was sooo bummed when the LA Rams got him it was the beginning of the end for me as a Rams fan...Vince farragamo and dick
fuck tens impossible now...try doing 20...then you get to csonka, motley, fuck cutis martin? ed James? so hard now...best with my eyes in my life? Bo and Barry....best ever? Jim....my all-time favs in order? Gale, Marcus, LT...
Re: NFL
The Bears finally won a home game after over a year . I know it's only one game with Tyson Bagent starting at QB, but this guy knows how to play the position, he looks like what used to be called a field general with his demeanor and quick decision making, only running when he has to. Yesterday the Bears looked like they had an O line, running game, tight ends, everything we were told we didn't have. All because of 1 reason, a different QB...the team has a pulse now. They play the Chargers next Sunday night. Now that's a team that has some quit in 'em, with a head coach who could be walking the green mile.