Aint No Right

bman wrote: Pumpkins were my 2nd favorite band from 91-96.... Have you ever seen the Pumpkins live? I have like 12 times and they are awful...

Saw them 12 times despite the fact they were awful....apparently this is a pattern with you that extends beyond Janes...

I'm just saying I'm seeing a pattern...I'm sorry if you don't like it!

Everybody's Friend wrote:I'm just saying I'm seeing a pattern...I'm sorry if you don't like it!

Your logic doesn't make sense. So you're saying Jane's is an awful live band?

EF, your thread made it to page 2. Can it make it past page 3?

Adurentibus Spina wrote: EF, your thread made it to page 2. Can it make it past page 3?

I bet it does, especially with kv involved, jeez, he could give you a whole page with one post! Just make sure people stay adversarial and pissed and I bet this goes 10, but I am not going to help much with this.
(hype, you put a bunch of carriage returns at the end of your post....you secretly want to help him out....... )
responding to ef: okay.

mockbee wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote: EF, your thread made it to page 2. Can it make it past page 3?

I bet it does, especially with kv involved, jeez, he could give you a whole page with one post. Just make sure people stay adversarial and pissed and I bet this goes 10, but I am not going to help much with this.

Get the hell out of my thread. Adversarial and pissed are the only good threads here.

kv wrote:comparing to pearl jam is sorta silly...they never broke up, never lost anyone within their song writing core...and pearl jam makes boring fucking music (imho of course) plus since pearl jam never broke up they have way more output...mainly because they were a much bigger commercial success and have a huge following which means more money to make...it's like comparing DRI to black flag...

We're talking about ticket value.

Jane's Addiction has 5 albums and still plays 10 song sets. Explain to me how losing a member of the band means they can't play lengthy sets.

But sure. I'll bite and go right along with your need to compare to another band who took a similar path.

How about THE BLACK CROWES?

They lost key members multiple times (in fact it's only down to 2 of the original 5), Broke up multiple times for lengthy hiatuses, Not boring, Singer and guitar player fight all the time about musical direction, Singer's shitty side bands are 1/100th as good as the main band, Singer sings in a high vocal range (like Perry does), had only 2-3 commercial hits, and have a fanbase obsessed with bootleg collection.

That work for you? Almost the exact same situation. Good? Good.

They mix up the set list every single night. EVERY SINGLE NIGHT. Their singer gets so wacked out on shrooms the guy can barely function, but still remembers the words every night and hits the notes.

They have 7 albums. Is that 2 more than Jane's? Sure. But they also play cover songs in their set on top of their own originals. Which means Jane's could throw in a cover or 2 as well if they feel they don't have the original content for a longer show. But they don't. Could, but won't.

Here's the last show The Black Crowes played:

http://www.setlist.fm/setlist/the-black ... 47695.html

17 songs.

According to this Crowes bootleg site:

http://www.crowesbase.com/tapelisting.cfm?TapeID=2922

Show Length: 130 minutes

That's an entire hour longer than Jane's Addiction plays.

Did that comparison work for you?

Everybody's Friend wrote:

bman wrote: Pumpkins were my 2nd favorite band from 91-96.... Have you ever seen the Pumpkins live? I have like 12 times and they are awful...

Saw them 12 times despite the fact they were awful....apparently this is a pattern with you that extends beyond Janes...

Sorry 67 doesn't work for me because you had to edit your post 3 times to get it right...here is a key point between the black crowes and janes now...janes sucks now..the end

Adurentibus Spina wrote: EF, your thread made it to page 2. Can it make it past page 3?

Odds are slowly coming down for a 16 page thread. Trust me.

We can do it

Tgea is my fav janes record it optimizes what real janes music is all about...fuck Casey

Discuss

I have two accounts on this site...kv and bman
Discuss

Etty is a warm hearted person the true soul of janes

Discuss

4 pages of remembering the moment perry became a hack?

I remember the exact moment I started saying this shit years ago and all you fucking hypocrites called me a hater


Discuss

Stp shits all over Jane and the Beatles

Discuss

Hey you live by in ( insert state or country here)? Fuck that place, loser donkey pig fuckers.


Discuss

I love the Celtics

I love zdilla

Creep dresses in women's clothing so he and his mom can play lesbian lovers

Es ty for policing us

Perk Mexico sucks

Art Canada sucka

Hype school sucks

Mxpxpppep metalica is crap

The neatherland and ausstrala suck at soccor

Panda your laser disk is broken and i are a paint drip on your space ship model

Larry chili...nuff said

Hoka is still scared of black people

If I missed you I want you to know I raped your dad



Discuss!

That should do it just PayPal me when we hit 15

is this really kv or an imposter?

Oh go make some shitty appetizer with Logan berries

I see you lurking Juana ...go raiders!

Yeah I don't annoy kv!

kv wrote:Sorry 67 doesn't work for me because you had to edit your post 3 times to get it right...here is a key point between the black crowes and janes now...janes sucks now..the end

Spelling mistakes. Fuck off.