Aint No Right

I really, really really like this song, and this album, and this band:

I dunno. Maybe PiL.

I find that a little post-punk goes a long way. It can get pretty cold and bleak, which is fine, for awhile. I love it as an ingredient in music that isn't necessarily completely post-punk. It's one of my favorite ingredients in the Jane's stew.

Love and Rockets counts.

there was a time in my life i could listen to that song nonstop

Adurentibus Spina wrote:Love and Rockets counts.

So...you're resetting the parameters to be pretty damn wide.

Post-punk is a pretty damn wide group. I don't even think it's a genre.

kv wrote:there was a time in my life i could listen to that song nonstop

even though it's not their song but the love and rockets song i couldn't stop listening to is:



and they aren't post punk.

I've never understood post punk so umm explain

download this:

creep wrote:

kv wrote:there was a time in my life i could listen to that song nonstop

even though it's not their song but the love and rockets song i couldn't stop listening to is:



and they aren't post punk.

bauhaus is post punk even though they were around in the 70's during punk much like siouxsie and the banshees...x sometimes called post punk along with television ..fugazi....the cure, jesus mary chain, joy div...it's all over the map

Juana wrote:I've never understood post punk so umm explain

I think it basically means late 70s and 80s alternative rock before Jane's basically invented it.

I have a boxed set called "Left of the Dial: Songs from the 80s Underground" that is basically entirely post-punk, but JA is on there, Ministry, etc. (But also Aztec Camera, Sisters of Mercy, Siouxsie, and so on).

Late 70s gothic rock is post punk because it was influenced by the 70s punk aesthetic and sound, but went beyond it to something different.

Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Adurentibus Spina wrote: Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Their first album, Boy, qualifies as post-punk in my books

Larry B. wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote: Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Their first album, Boy, qualifies as post-punk in my books

That sounds like a really bad throwaway Cure song with shittier musicians and vocals.

Adurentibus Spina wrote:

Larry B. wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote: Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Their first album, Boy, qualifies as post-punk in my books

That sounds like a really bad throwaway Cure song with shittier musicians and vocals.

Oh no you didint.....

I have never loved and hated a band like I do U2. The first 3 are a few of my all times.....Rattle and Hum, fun....the rest

SR wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote:

Larry B. wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote: Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Their first album, Boy, qualifies as post-punk in my books

That sounds like a really bad throwaway Cure song with shittier musicians and vocals.

Oh no you didint.....

I have never loved and hated a band like I do U2. The first 3 are a few of my all times.....Rattle and Hum, fun....the rest

I just described what it sounds like to my ear...

I know, I know....

SR wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote:

Larry B. wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote: Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Their first album, Boy, qualifies as post-punk in my books

That sounds like a really bad throwaway Cure song with shittier musicians and vocals.

Oh no you didint.....

I have never loved and hated a band like I do U2. The first 3 are a few of my all times.....Rattle and Hum, fun....the rest

ditto i loved U2 they were the shit first 3 records they lost me at joshua tree

Adurentibus Spina wrote:

Juana wrote:I've never understood post punk so umm explain

I think it basically means late 70s and 80s alternative rock before Jane's basically invented it.

I have a boxed set called "Left of the Dial: Songs from the 80s Underground" that is basically entirely post-punk, but JA is on there, Ministry, etc. (But also Aztec Camera, Sisters of Mercy, Siouxsie, and so on).

Late 70s gothic rock is post punk because it was influenced by the 70s punk aesthetic and sound, but went beyond it to something different.

Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Post punk really is a nebulous term or category when you get right down to it. I'd say Post-Punk is a label for almost like anything post 1978 - pre 90's as long as there's few if any guitar solos in the songs and a typically sparse, dry production. Many of the bands that at some point early in their career like say, The Cult or Killing Joke quickly evolved or at least became pigeon-holed in other genres like Metal, Industrial, Goth, Hard Rock, etc (in their case). For instance, is the first Pretenders album post-punk? IMO, yes but everything they did after that falls into more traditional rock/power pop.

Pandemonium wrote:

Adurentibus Spina wrote:

Juana wrote:I've never understood post punk so umm explain

I think it basically means late 70s and 80s alternative rock before Jane's basically invented it.

I have a boxed set called "Left of the Dial: Songs from the 80s Underground" that is basically entirely post-punk, but JA is on there, Ministry, etc. (But also Aztec Camera, Sisters of Mercy, Siouxsie, and so on).

Late 70s gothic rock is post punk because it was influenced by the 70s punk aesthetic and sound, but went beyond it to something different.

Even U2 is apparently post-punk.

Post punk really is a nebulous term or category when you get right down to it. I'd say Post-Punk is a label for almost like anything post 1978 - pre 90's as long as there's few if any guitar solos in the songs and a typically sparse, dry production. Many of the bands that at some point early in their career like say, The Cult or Killing Joke quickly evolved or at least became pigeon-holed in other genres like Metal, Industrial, Goth, Hard Rock, etc (in their case). For instance, is the first Pretenders album post-punk? IMO, yes but everything they did after that falls into more traditional rock/power pop.

I'd say both Pretender's 1&2 are "post punk"....then they lost half the band and it was all downhll from there.