Aint No Right

Of all of the actresses, how is it this woman was chosen to play Marilyn Monroe? The reviews of My Week With Marilyn have been fairly positive. I cannot stand Michelle Williams. MM is rolling in her grave.

http://www.variety.com/review/VE1117946328/

http://community.nytimes.com/rate-revie ... n/overview

I have to agree she is a surprising choice.
The only movie I've seen her in is Wendy and Lucy. Other than that, I can't think what else she's been in.

dawsons creek!



sort of an odd choice of an actress to hate

oh yeah, i forgot about dawson's creek.

i never watched that show. i don't think even 1 episode.

Artemis wrote:I have to agree she is a surprising choice.
The only movie I've seen her in is Wendy and Lucy. Other than that, I can't think what else she's been in.

dear god.



Lucy!................................................................................Lucy!.............................................[whistle]................................................

..................................................[whistle]......................................................................................................
..........................................................................................Here girl!...................................................



There is the entire script if anyone is interested.

I saw her in Brokeback Mountain and Blue Valentine. I wasn't impressed with either of her performances.

I don't get the Michelle Williams thing at all. I mean, who the hell did she sleep with in order to start getting work with A-List directors like Ang Lee, Martin Scorcese, and Sam Raimi?! She's not very attractive...even by "normal" people standards, let alone Hollywood standards; I wouldn't do a double take if she was walking down the street...hell, I wouldn't even notice her, period. And as chaos said, her performances haven't been anything special.

Btw, the answer to the question I posed is Heath Ledger.



To me, she has that homely Anne Hathaway thing going on.

Homely?

Anne Hathaway is way more attractive than Michelle Williams (by anyone's standards). I never really cared for her as an actress until I saw her in Rachel Getting Married. I was surprised by how good she was in that movie.

chaos wrote:Homely?

Anne Hathaway is way more attractive than Michelle Williams (by anyone's standards). I never really cared for her as an actress until I saw her in Rachel Getting Married. I was surprised by how good she was in that movie.

yeah that was a great movie and she was really good. she has her moments but i thought she looked really good in that movie too.

i thought michelle williams was cute on dawsons creek....not that i watched that show.

chaos wrote:Homely?

Anne Hathaway is way more attractive than Michelle Williams (by anyone's standards). I never really cared for her as an actress until I saw her in Rachel Getting Married. I was surprised by how good she was in that movie.

To me, it's all smoke and mirrors (a good makeup artist). When I look at her, I see a dorky, mousey girl with esteem issues. I could easily find a better looking young woman on a college campus in about 5 minutes. I'm just not attracted to her at all.

Tyler Durden wrote:

chaos wrote:Homely?

Anne Hathaway is way more attractive than Michelle Williams (by anyone's standards). I never really cared for her as an actress until I saw her in Rachel Getting Married. I was surprised by how good she was in that movie.

To me, it's all smoke and mirrors (a good makeup artist). When I look at her, I see a dorky, mousey girl with esteem issues. I could easily find a better looking young woman on a college campus in about 5 minutes. I'm just not attracted to her at all.

Her teeth are practically leaping out of her mouth.

Anne has never done a thing for me. I see more attractive women downtown daily.

Artemis wrote:I have to agree she is a surprising choice.
The only movie I've seen her in is Wendy and Lucy. Other than that, I can't think what else she's been in.

She's been on that Scorcese movie, Shutter Island or something like that? the gay cowboy movie (Brokeback mountain) I think she's a fairly good actress, read in Vanity Fair she's great in this one.
And don't diss on Anne She's been great both times she's hosted SNL. Loved especially the first time in which she portrayed Mary Poppins and when they sang supercalifragilistic, they were talking about an STD she passed to all the guys
I don't remember the name of the movie, but she was in one with Bijou Phillips and they hang with some Mexican gangsters. That one was ok

Why the hate. She's not bad at all....

I think they're both attractive, I don't understand why they'd cast Michelle Williams as Monroe though.

I just can't believe how old Judi Dench looks

lollapaloser wrote:I think they're both attractive, I don't understand why they'd cast Michelle Williams as Monroe though.

I understand why. Anne looks nothing like Marilyn Monroe. Michelle on the other hand does. If I had to sit through a movie where Anne played Marilyn it would require extreme suspension of disbelief on my part. Michelle might not be as good an actor but at least she visually fits the part (which is enormously important here) and will probably get the job done just fine.

she already did the job and it doesn't look that bad...
Anne was never cast as Marilyn

Tyler Durden wrote:I don't get the Michelle Williams thing at all. I mean, who the hell did she sleep with in order to start getting work with A-List directors like Ang Lee, Martin Scorcese, and Sam Raimi?! She's not very attractive...even by "normal" people standards, let alone Hollywood standards; I wouldn't do a double take if she was walking down the street...hell, I wouldn't even notice her, period. And as chaos said, her performances haven't been anything special.

Btw, the answer to the question I posed is Heath Ledger.



To me, she has that homely Anne Hathaway thing going on.

Maybe it's because she can act?

Perhaps she's talented?

Would you rather have Megan Fox terrible up every good movie on the planet just because she's gorgeous?